Would You Rather? – Harry Potter

Hey guys! So I feel like starting up another series of posts about something (kind of like the Silly Sentences). After a lot of thinking, I finally decided on doing…

Would You Rather? – Book (or movie) edition!

Hopefully this will go well

So here is my first Would You Rather: HARRY POTTER EDITION!

YAYYYYYYY!!!!!

It’s pretty simple: read the questions I made up. Pick an answer (try your best not to say ‘both’!). Comment them.

If we get a lot of comments, you can compare your opinion to other people’s opinions

I’ll also be answering them, so you can see what I think, and see how different our opinions are

HARRY POTTER SPOILERS! (duh)

Here we go!

WOULD YOU RATHER…?

1. Be a part of Dumbledore’s Army, or the Order of the Phoenix?
2. Be a part of the original Order of the Phoenix (James’s time), or the second Order of the Phoenix (Harry’s time)?
3. Be killed by Voldemort, or serve Voldemort for the rest of your life?
4. Visit Zonko’s Joke Shop, or Honeyduke’s?
5. Save Sirius Black or Remus Lupin?
6. Save Nymphadora Tonks or Mad Eye Moody?
7. Be a rat for 12 years straight (like Peter Pettigrew/Wormtail), or be in Azkaban for 12 years straight (like Sirius Black)?
8. Be a Dursley or Malfoy?
9. Save Dobby or Hedwig?
10. Listen to Neville Longbottom talking about Herbology for 4 hours straight, or Luna Lovegood talking about non-existing things that she believes in for 4 hours straight?
11. Save Albus Dumbledore or James Potter?
12. Save Fred or Lily Evans/Potter?
13. Be in Gryffindor or Slytherin?
14. Be in Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff?
15. Be a Seeker or a Chaser?
16. Be a Beater or a Keeper?
17. Buy a bag of Dungbombs or a box of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans?
18. Have a box of Chocolate Frogs or a box of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans?
19. Be an Animagus or be a Metamorphmagus?
20. Read the entire Harry Potter series in one day or watch the entire Harry Potter series in one day?

Now for my opinion!

1. Hm… I think the Order of the Phoenix, but only just, though
2. The Order of the Phoenix II – in the Order of the Phoenix (the book!), Mad Eye and Lupin talked about how most of the original Order died, so you can probably see why I want to be in the second one (of course people died, but less people in the second Order died)
3. I would rather be killed by Voldemort
4. Honeyduke’s
5. WHAT!? I DO NOT WANT TO KILL EITHERRRRRRR!!!!! I AM SORRY BUT I CANNOT CHOOSE! BOTH WERE AMAZING AND PLAYED SUCH A BIG PART TO BOTH JAMES AND HARRY
6. Tough one… I think I would have to say Mad Eye – but Tonks is awesome too
7. I guess it depends. I would prefer to be a rat for 12 years – Azkaban is horrible. But if the sitiuation was like how it was for Sirius – the Dementors didn’t affect Sirius because he knew he was innocent – then I don’t know. Maybe Azkaban if I knew I was innocent? Being a rat doesn’t sound awfully nice
8. I’d rather be a Malfoy, hands down. WHO WOULD WANT TO BE A DURSLEY? LIKE COME ON!
9. I DON’T KNOW! BOTH WERE SO INNOCENT, AND THEY DIDN’T DESERVE TO DIE, AND THEY WERE BOTH SO CLOSE TO HARRY… I’m sorry Hedwig, but I’m saving Dobby
10. I would rather be with Luna, although it would probably drive me crazy. I didn’t pick Neville only because I know nothing about Herbology
11. I DON’T KNOW. Dumbledore was a big person in Harry’s life – he played a massive part to destroying Voldemort, and to society in general. James, on the other hand, also was fighting Voldemort, and he was Harry’s father. Then again, if I saved James, he would be devasted without Lily with him… This is impossible
12. That’s basically asking myself whether I think it’s more important for George to have his twin back, or for Harry to have his mother back. I think it would be more important to bring George’s twin back, but then again, Lily played a big part in fighting Voldemort before she died, and maybe everything wouldn’t turn out so bad if Lily was back. So I guess I’m going with bringing back Lily
13. Gryffindor. I am already in Gryffindor. Not that I have anything against Slytherin! I know they aren’t just ‘the evil house’!
14. Tough one. I would probably do better in Ravenclaw, but kindness, being hard-working, friendship, and Hufflepuff in general is so underestimated. I’m not sure
15. Chaser. I am a Chaser. Seeker is probably more thrilling and interesting, but I suck at catching small things XD
16. Hm… I think Beater – although I would fail at both
17. Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans – Dungbombs would be cool, but there’s not really a big reason for why I would want them. I don’t prank people that often (although I pranked some people with my friend Annabelle – if you want to see some of the pranks we did, look on the side and find the tag ‘Pranks’). Also, Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans would be so fun!
18. Close one, but I think I have to go with Chocolate Frogs. Chocolate is yummy, and the cards are awesome to collect!
19. Animagus. That would be so freaking cool to turn into an animal at will
20. Although the movies are great, DEFNITELY THE BOOKS!

WHAT DO YOU GUYS THINK!?